I take no credit for that. The list has been running since about the 15th page or something. I think John started it initially, it's just been a collaborative work after that.
And I'd like to see this thread revived, and I have a proposition:
Most of the big artists were reviewed 5+ years ago. I would love to see people (new people, not the original reviewers) take on some of the artists reviewed in here and give their own views. Even if the grades occasionally agree, the views are going to differ, and it'd make for interesting reading. C'mon kids, give me a reason to want to listen to Pixies again.