I went to both weekends, and they were both epic coachellaness. Musically, I definitely had incomparable, transcendent moments at both. It is really really hard to pick a favorite, but I'll have to go with Weekend 2 FTW, only because the weather was better. Yes, I prefer 108 degrees at 2p at Outdoor to trying to enjoy Radiohead in 54 degrees. The only perk of Coldchella was sitting in the rain with my bff of 16 years watching Mazzy while rolling balls--that was magical. Other than that the cold was almost unbearable for me (yes I am a California native...brrrrr!).
Just wanted to hear your opinions on if/how you decided on a favorite, I know there are plenty of Both Weekend Warriors out there to chip in their $0.02.