Fuddruckers vs. Five Guys burgers

[citizenerased]

A current hot debate

[newnostalgia]

hahahaha.

[newnostalgia]

where's The in n out option..

[daxton]

I'm sad I didn't get to try In n Out when I was in CA.

[Fourthisto]

Five Guys, but if Smashburger was on the list... I'd go that way.

where's The in n out option..

+100,578

[PlayaDelWes]

Why is Fuddruckers an option?

[citizenerased]

I'm sorry! I'm just putting this argument to rest. I love in n out.

[choice cat]

never had five guys, but fuddruckers is really fucking good.

[DFrank]

Fuddruckers is mah shit. Ate there after AYSO soccer games.

[Chromezeppelin]

fudd's is legit but in & out is an institution

a double double with fries is the most delicious thing on earth

[fatbastard]

Sign just went up for the 5 guys on fig by USC. I'd say 5 guys is an adequate substitute for those that don't have an in-n-out near them. If in-n-out is a 10 then 5 guys is a 7.75. Fuddruckers closed in Pasadena many years ago. The staff was fighting the flies as they were preparing my order on our last visit.

[zircona1]

I voted Fuddruckers, I've only been there once (there's one in town) but I remember enjoying my burger.

Five Guys isn't that great and it's too expensive. In-N-Out FTW.

[Theijuiel]

Now I need to get myself some Fuddruckers, it has been years.

[Timestretch]

Fatted Calf, Clayton MO
McConnels Pub, STL
Becks Prime, Houston

[getbetter]

I actually crave five guys unlike in n out

[prickly]

Fuddruckers hands down.

[york707]

Fatted Calf, Clayton MO
McConnels Pub, STL
Becks Prime, Houston

Timestretch, I don't know you, but what do you think of the burger at Blueberry Hill and Seamus McDaniel's? Carl's Drive-in?

[Boourns]

Fuddrucker's buns cant be beat

[NachoCat]

Fuddruckers , because I can get a fuckin pounder there. No , no..not a quarter pounder. A pounder. As in 1 full fuckin pound of beef on a loaf of bread for a bun.

And a milkshake.

[Neighborhood Creep]

Fuddruckers , because I can get a fuckin pounder there. No , no..not a quarter pounder. A pounder. As in 1 full fuckin pound of beef on a loaf of bread for a bun.

And a milkshake.

This. And their awesome nachos are awesome

[betao]

Fuddrucker's buns cant be beat

THIS.

[TomAz]

Why is Fuddruckers an option?

This is, word for word, what I was just about to post. Fuddruckers is the Applebee's of hamburger joints. No thank you.

[sonofhal]

Will have to sample a Fuddruckers in Jan. As much as I love In n out, I prefer Five Guys meat. (post your gay orgy jokes below).

[citizenerased]

Man this thread got bumped big time. And for the record I made it Fuddruckers vs Five Guys because that's all people were talking about at the time.

[canexplain]

I remember when Fuddruckers first opened here and when you walked in they had all the meat hanging behind these large windows for everyone to see like an old butcher shop. That's a no no here now anyway.... cr****

[C DUB YA]

No Fuddruckers in Ohio anymore. A new 5 Guys opens up every week though.

[Neighborhood Creep]

That Kris Humphrey/Kardashian guy owns the 5 Guys that is a few minute drive from me. Douche burgers

[Boourns]

The last time I had a Five Guys burger, it was pretty craptastic. Fries were still ace, though.

I was actually craving Fuddrucker's since I haven't been in a few years, but it seems the last one around here just closed down back in October.

[Timestretch]

Timestretch, I don't know you, but what do you think of the burger at Blueberry Hill and Seamus McDaniel's? Carl's Drive-in?

Blueberry Hill isn't close to my favorite, but you can get a great burger there with soft-spread cheddar for around $5. It's a great bargain. It's probably the best burger for the price. Seamus is over-rated. It's a frozen patty that breaks apart in clumps when you eat it. I do know people that love Seamus.

Carl's isn't comparable to the rest because it's a thin greasy diner burger. It's good if you want that style of burger and they have the original IBC root beer on cask, but to me there's a clear distinction between the two styles of hamburger and I don't compare them. In n Out and all the fast food joints like 5 Guys would be in this category for me. My favorite thin style hamburgers are Blimpy Burger in Ann Arbor and Dirty Martins in Austin.

[theklein25]

Loved Fuddruckers and then it closed, then a month later they opened a Five Guys a couple blocks away. I'd rather have Fuddruckers back.