I'm sorry but voting for a band with 1.5 albums under their belt is VERY DUMB. Most of these other bands have 5 or more albums...thats when you can judge stuff like this.
And yes, Im referring to whoever voted for the Arcade Fire.
Great band, but too young to be compared to some of these truly legendary, groundbreaking musicians. That doesn't mean their music isn't as good, but consistency and continued creativity mean a lot also. They need to put a few more albums out before you can rate them higher than bands with albums on every top 100 list ever published for rock music.