Watch ANY clip of them playing live and tell me you'd like to hear him sing. I've said it before and I'll say it again. They should reunite without Ian and let the crowd sing. Check out how awful he was at the Manchester cancer show until he stepped back and let thousands of people sing the chorus of I Am The Ressurection. http://youtube.com/watch?v=Adx3wLFDU9M I saw a Roses tribute band in Scotland and you couldn't hear the singer because everyone was singing....and then Mani hopped up and played She Bangs The Drums. Yikes.