Good to know, person none of us give a shit about.
Good to know, person none of us give a shit about.
3/8: Voices from the Lake LIVE @ Monarch
3/17: Forest Swords @ The Independent
3/19: Tycho @ The Catalyst
3/22: St. Vincent @ The Fox
3/22: Dance Mania & Mister Saturday Night @ PW
3/23: Kraftwerk @ The Fox
4/6: Trentemoller @ Mezzanine
4/15: The Knife @ The Fox
4/16: Factory Floor @ The Independent
4/17: The Afghan Whigs @ Slim's
4/26: Simian Mobile Disco, Earth @ Pappy and Harriet's
5/2-5/4: Austin Psych Fest @ Carson Creek Ranch
And of course we'd be having this argument, because you like those kinds of bands more than I do, and I like stuff that's a little more "out there" than you do (not trying to be condescending, but you know what I mean). And those types of bands that have a stronger appeal to you are getting more spots on the lineup at the expense of the type of bands that appeal to me. That's what I mean by balance. Yes there's variety, of course. But there's not as many bands like, say from years past, Liars, Animal Collective, Throbbing Gristle, My Bloody Valentine, Public Image Ltd, Lightning Bolt, etc. I feel like the slightly more abrasive, forward thinking bands with limited appeal are starting to get cut out of the picture in order to make room for more bands that are just y'know "nice." And there's also just a whole lot of repeats and old shoe acts. Booking someone like the Black Lips is so extremely lazy when there's a hundred bands in SF making a similar kind of racket who haven't oversaturated the festival market. I think that's kind of the point too. Oversaturation. We're getting the familiar and the established far more than the new and the untested, and that takes some of the fun out of it.
And obviously I'm just trying to explain to you WHY some of us feel the lineup is on the underwhelming side instead of prove you wrong for liking it. I don't think you're stupid for liking it, it's good, but to dismiss people as "You're spoiled, you live in a big city, this is the same as every year, shut up whiner" is just as stupid as dismissing someone for liking NPR indie rock-lite.
It certainly doesn't help when bands like Lightning Bolt play to 20 people and are followed by a flurry of comments by people who wandered in and out saying "that was the worst music i ever heard!" They were fucking great last year btw.
But just as Coachella is changing its appeal for people, it makes it easier for people to switch gears and go to things like ATP, DEMF, etc that CLEARLY are geared toward a very different audience.
The reason Coachella has always pulled me in is for nostalgia acts and British bands. The reason I started going (in 2005) was because of Doves (I'm still hurting), Kasabian, and Stereophonics. After that it was Massive Attack and Depeche Mode. 2007 was one of my favorites with Jarvis Cocker and The Good, The Bad, and the Queen (at the time, I thought it was as close as I would get to Pulp and Blur). 2008 had Spiritualized. 2009 had Paul McCartney, Paul Weller, and The Cure. 2010 was actually sort of a low year for my kind of stuff, even though it had Gorillaz. I still enjoyed that year, but it seemed like a very different experience. Was this is also when clusterfuckchella happened? That made it different, too. 2011 delivered big time with Suede, Elbow, Big Audio Dynamite, and Duran Duran. Last year was definitely one of my favorite years. So anyway, those are all acts that lured me in, and as you can imagine, with acts like Pulp, Noel Gallagher, and Radiohead (who I have never seen, although I will see before Coachella), this year's line-up is another success for me.
I also really like a lot of those buzz bands, too - which more than make the trip to see those specific bands worth it. I definitely like Jeff Magnum. I can hardly think of another album that makes me want to sing along more than In the Aeroplane Over the Sea, hype or no hype.
And I bring up the "you live in a big city" thing in response to people who are saying that they have chances to see these artists throughout the year. I think overexposure, due to living in a big city, can cloud someone's view of the lineup. It's probably obvious, but still overlooked. I don't mean to be a dick, except when I'm joking with some of the LA folks for complaining that "sometimes it sucks living in LA because there are so many options."
THIS EMBARRASSMENT OF RICHES HAS ME ABSOLUTELY AGHAST
like when Paul McCartney finally toured Uganda
Yeah, living in a big city makes it easier to skip fests and living in a smaller city/town that gets skipped a lot makes fests more appealing. I do want to go to Coachella this year, and I want to see a ton of bands that don't come near me or who I don't want to go out of my way and pay a lot of money for their own show, but like I said before, priorities.
Now that we've all reached perfect harmony and agreement, let's step away before the house of cards collapses.
If my assumption is correct that Coachella 2012 sold 2/3 of the gate prior to the line-up drop, maybe 3/4, then that's a strong argument that it's not so much anymore about the Coachella, the music rather COACHELLA, THE EVENT. For better or worse.
GV could have booked Creed, Hannah Montana, and Insane Clown Posse as headliners and we'd still be looking at a sell out. (Ok, so maybe a little hyperbole there.)
As for you serious music connoisseurs out there, (you know who you are) you make some cogent points why you're staying away. I get your points even if I don't feel your pain. This will be my third Coachella and I am still giddy; (see Coachella vs Christmas Morning thread.) Perhaps after the ninth or tenth I'll feel differently.
All I know is that I will get to see 25 to 30 bands in a weekend at one of the most spectacular outdoor venues imaginable with a nearly 100% guarantee of no rain. And I won't have to drive. No way I get to that many shows the rest of the year given work and family commitments. Like many of you, I felt more than a twinge of disappointment on line-up day. But I have been reading about and listening to and digging much of this undercard and I know that when the set times come down, the usual conflicts will arise.
So, barring any unforeseen calamities (stabbing, shooting, kidnapping, gang-rape, insert your favorite) I plan on drinking and dancing and having a dandy time for three days next month. With any luck, I'll get to pre-game with same gang of bacchanalian Aussies in the campgrounds. It is not going to suck.
I bought a pass to last year's fest, but didn't go due to not having enough vacation time available from work (I had enough, but I woulda been screwed by July if I had gone). I thought the lineup was as shitty last year as it's ever been. So I didn't think I'd miss not going that much. But we had a snowstorm that weekend in Minnesota. I watched the webcast that weekend when I wasn't at work. It was torture. I really regretted not being there. It didn't help reading the mostly good experiences you guys had, combo'd with them fixing the clusterfuck of 2010. So I'm happy to be back. I recommend not watching the webcast if you don't go. It put me in a sour mood.
But you can't force these things if you're not into it. I know for a fact this will be my last year for quite some time, possibly ever. Times and people and events change. But you fucking better be excited about staying with us, we have big things in store. In fact, what are you thoughts on confetti? I'm thinking of going a little overboard this year . . .
Who gives a shit. You're either going or you're not. It's fucking March; get over it already people.
(Btw, Patrick is owning this godforsaken thread. Insert "nailed it" photo here.)
I give a shit because some of these people are my friends and I genuinely look forward to hanging out with them, such as you and I did during Trentemoller last year. That was a good time and I look forward to having more good times with you people.
And while it may seem like I'm responding to your hyperbole it works even applied to a weak line-up. With the advance purchases the lineup for 2012 is going to have the most effect on ticket sales for 2013. It's a weird system and leads to exactly the sort of thing people are expressing/bemoaning in this thread. But, hey, that is the cost of being popular.
2014 Collaborative Playlist on Spotify.
I get what you're saying, Patrick. But if you really wanted to, you can pick up every single poster in the history of Coachella and find a significant percentage of the lineup to fit the categories you describe. Of course if the lineup doesn't blow you away, I can't blame you for no travelling to the other side of the country to attend a festival.
A year or two off isn't a bad thing. I really wish I hadn't missed six straight years, but I have no regrets missing Coachella in 2005, 2007 or 2009.
Last edited by GuyInTucson; 03-07-2012 at 08:34 AM.
new order into nin into prodigy was stellar. that was also the year of the best chems performance i've ever seen. marky and roni size were dope. it was an overall good year for BASS i think.
i wish i would have seen MF doom, aesop rock, blackstar, and four tet.
I would have deep regrets for missing 2007. Amy Winehouse's big break, The Jesus and Mary Chain, Comedians of Comedy, Jarvis Cocker, The Good The Bad and The Queen, and Bjork!?
Red Hot Chili Peppers!?!?!?!?
I am not a fan of NIN at all; I saw Prodigy three years prior on the main and their show was really good then too. I just see a lot of stuff I shrug at that year (which is how many people look at this year's lineup). There are a few acts there I would have liked to see, but nothing really jumping out at me in 2005.
I feel the same way about 2009, although I did attempt to go that year because it had been so long and I wanted to get the hell out of Tucson and see Paul McCartney and Leonard Cohen. That plan fell through.
Doesn't like NIN or Bjork... I don't understand it, but I'll believe it. I don't like Bjork's new album, but I loved her set at Coachella. She played a ton of my favorite songs.
If I had to miss a year, I think I would have missed 2010. But a lot of that might have to do with being in Manhattan, where I was all over a lot of those bands before and after Coachella. The most painful thing would have been missing Echo & the Bunnymen, because they had cancelled the New York concert I had tickets for, and I had been dying to see them (more than anything on the line-up, even). I also would have missed Faith No More. I wouldn't have realized how my life would be a little lower in quality than it is today, having seen them and learned.