First saw them 11/28/2008 at the Casbah and had been listening for some months prior, so I'm not too recent a fan, but that was Microcastle era. I started with Turn It Up though before moving on. Last.fm tells me I've listened to Microcastle the most, but Cryptograms is my favorite. Been hooked on HD lately of course, but you've made me realize I need to listen to some of their earlier stuff again/more often. Especially Fluorescent Grey, which I certainly do love, but for all it's goodness, I definitely have not spent enough time with it.