fist fuck! > tool
Nine Inch Nails
NIN is winning woothoo!
just because these bands have overlap of fans (pretty considerable overlap) doesn't make them a good comparison.
tool and nin are completely different animals in terms of their philosophies toward making music and playing it live
I picked Tool but I love both.
"ain't no thang but a chicken wang"
Coachella 06, 07, 08, 09, 10, 11Lollapalooza 95, 96, 97, 03, 08
Rock The Bells 07, 09, 10
Vegoose 07, RIP
Mile High 09
6/9 - Deftones/Dillenger | 6/10 - Cake | 6/17 - Buckethead | 6/28 - Glitch Mob | 7/25 - APC | 7/30 - LA Rising (Rage, Muse, Lauryn Hill, Rise Against) | 8/12 - Cut//Copy
I love both bands but prefer TOOL. Anyways its fuckin retarded to compare numer of songs played by each band on setlists since TOOL songs are significantly longer.
I mean in some of the setlists posted Pushit (Salival) is about 15min live and Reflection is about 12min live.
The average Tool song is about twice as long as any NIN song. I'm not voting but my opinion is this: Tool collectively > NIN. Trent Reznor individually > any one member of Tool.
I think Tool has the better band. They are a tight and solid band that consistently puts on one of the best sounding live performances. I think NIN produces better art, shows more creativity and has taken far more chances than Tool and has mostly been successful in doing so.
I pick NIN because I like more of their music and appreciate the quality of the material that comes from exploring new sounds.
I love Tool, but I think NIN is a far superior live show.
6/15/14 Failure - Glasshouse // 7/9/14 Cloud Nothings/Metz - Roxy
7/16/14 Planes Mistaken For Stars - Echo // 8/23-24/14 FYF Fest - Expo Park //8/25/14 Nine Inch Nails - Hollywood Bowl // 9/12-14/14 Riotfest - Humboldt Park, Chicago, IL
9/18/14 Neutral Milk Hotel - Hollywood Bowl
Far superior? That's a bit much.
There is no live experience equal to DC behind the kit.
There is no live percussion experience equal to that, no. I'll take Robin over Adam on lead guitar.
However, Adam's playing is much more creative and imaginative than one might think; he doesn't play to showcase how badass of a guitar player he is (e.g. seldom will he shred for a solo).
For example, slide guitar on Third Eye or talk box solo on Jambi. . . I rest my case.
both are great live, I choose NIN over Tool cuz they have a more electronic feel and I lean towards that rather than the "organic" sound of Tool, plus I dont pay $60 to watch silhouettes....flame on...also
September 10, 2009
Los Angeles, CA
The Wiltern Theater
March Of The Pigs
Something I Can Never Have
Just Like You Imagined (w/ Mike Garson)
La Mer (w/ Mike Garson)
Eraser (w/ Mike Garson)
The Becoming (w/ Mike Garson)
Down in the Park Mike Garson Instrumental
Down In The Park (w/ Gary Numan)
Metal (w/ Gary Numan)
I Die, You Die (w/ Gary Numan)
Down In It
The Hand That Feeds
Head Like A Hole
Me, I'm Not (w/ Atticus Ross)
The Warning (w/ Atticus Ross and Dave Navarro)
Piggy (Nothing Can Stop Me Now) (w/ Atticus Ross and Dave Navarro)
Gave Up (w/ Dave Navarro)
Mr. Self Destruct (w/ Greg Puciato and Ben Weinman)
Wish (w/ Dillinger Escape Plan)
The Good Soldier
The Day The World Went Away
In This Twilight
Last edited by Aphxtwinin; 08-16-2010 at 09:03 PM.
I love how Trent plays 800 songs in his setlist and chooses not to play Closer, that prick. On his farewell tour.
This has nothing to do with the topic or anything, just pissed me off when I saw them.
Ron Paul 2012!
Death Cab for Cutie/Magik Magik Orchestra
some other bands
That's tight, huh; how he did that?
"Closer" has been played a lot, now "Meet your Master" would of been amazing.