The Stones or The Who

[keith]

The Rolling Stones were rumored and The Who were going to play but didn't last year. Who would you rather see at Coachella?

[aloeV]

Rolling Stones. I'd love to hear Give Me Shelter live while partying with all my Coachella friends. Never been too into The Who.

COACHELLA 2011: UNDERWORLD * DAFT PUNK * OUTKAST * SOUNDGARDEN * DUCK SAUCE * FUKKK OFFF * GOTAN PROJECT * SQUAREPUSHER *SIMIAN MOBILE DISCO * GREEN VELVET * FLYING LOTUS * BOYZ NOISE * BIRDY NAM NAM * BOOKA SHADE * ZZ TOP * JILL SCOTT * MR. BUNGLE =)

[gaypalmsprings]

I'd love to hear the Rolling Stones cover a Phish album.

[TomAz]

I have seen both bands multiple times. I find the Who's music is wearing better over the years than the Stones'. Plus I fucking hate "Start Me Up".

[JamesMills]

Mick Jagger can still bang live. Daltrey, not so much.

[djandrews25]

Jagger looks like a 75 year old transgender on stage. The Who all the way.

[Geno_g]

The Who...

[instinct]

My parents are die hard Stones fans.. so I vote for the Who.

[psycobetabuckdown]

I have seen both bands multiple times. I find the Who's music is wearing better over the years than the Stones'. Plus I fucking hate "Start Me Up".

I like The Who better, but The Rolling Stones would just be a better show in 2010...err, 2011.

[TomAz]

I last saw the Who in 2000 and it was a damned good show. I saw the Stones in like 02 and it was sort of just okay.

[amyzzz]

Don't really care for the Stones. The Who sounds more Britpoppy which makes me happy.

[Drinkey McDrinkerstein]

I last saw the Who in 2000 and it was a damned good show. I saw the Stones in like 02 and it was sort of just okay.

I saw them in 2002, two days after Entwistle's death, and they were still AMAZING. It was a hell of a show.

[rage patton]

I saw The Who in 2006 and it was an awesome show. The blew away all my expectations. I would love to see The Who at Coachella next year.

If the Rolling Stones were playing, I would go check out whoever was on another stage.

[Mr. Fuzz]

After a long day at Coachella I don't think that there could be anything better than the Stones.

[djandrews25]

After a long day at Coachella I don't think that there could be anything better than the Stones.

Not even a band that can still actually play?

[mickflyy]

Yeah A DJ set in the Sahara would be better.

[JamesMills]

Wow, lots of hate for one of the best rock bands of all time. I haven't seen either live, but I saw The Who put forth one of the worst live performances I've ever seen at the last Super Bowl while The Stones put on the best Super Bowl performance of the decade the year before.

I'm not sure that constitutes as enough to make an accurate judgment, but I'll just say that Jagger was visibly energetic and sounded great while Daltrey looked (and sounded) torpid.

I'm a huge Who fan, too. Loved them since I was a little kid while I only recently really got into the Stones a few years ago.

[sin213]

i definitely hope the who are there this year. stones are great, but nah...they'd probably all have heart attacks from the heat before they got on stage.

[ballroomdancer22]

Arcade Fire