We had something like this up in the old board and I think Brad was going to make a metalist from all of our individual rankings...did that ever happen? I never saw the results if it did.
My top five were:
1. The Hold Steady - Boys and Girls in America
2. The Coup - Pick a Bigger Weapon
3. The Decemberists - The Crane Wife
4. Tapes 'n Tapes - The Loon
5. Gnarls Barkley - St. Elsewhere
Here's more if you're interested. Put yours down in this thread if you haven't already.