Untitled 8 vs You Made Me Realise

[betao]

They both have reputations as being the ultimate set closers.

Which one do you prefer?

Sigur Ros's "Untitled 8" or My Bloody Valentine's "You Made Me Realise"?

I honestly don't know for myself.

[TeamCoachellaHellYeah]

I haven't been there for YMMR...I will not vote until I do...

[garrett222]

EASY Sigur ros.

[TeamCoachellaHellYeah]

have you been to live MBV garrett?

[ivankay]

Damn, i tried to respond twice and nothing. One more time:

Tough one.

i'm still coming off the high of experiencing YMMR last week. i suspect the INTENSITY of it will be with me forever.

Untitled 8 rocks big time for the last part and it's glory brought tears to my eyes at the 2005 Bowl show.

i'm going with YMMR because i never felt anything like that at a show or anywhere. It was as if i was going through the womb experience all over again and grew a third eye in the process. That shit was flat out nuts.

[Cdubby]

EASY MBV.

[Boourns]

Wow. This is actually a tough poll. Good job.

Untitled 8 is my favorite thing ever, but what MBV does with You Made Me Realize is so wtf...I don't know. Must think about it.

[betao]

Seriously. These are the songs that while during the concerts of either band, you are waiting just to be blown away by the ending tunes.

I have yet too see either, so I picked the one that I want to see most, which is YMMR. I want to feel the noise.

[idrive1life]

Easy, abstained.

[Boourns]

I had to go with Sigur Ros. MBV is more mind (and ear) shattering, but I found Untitled 8 to be more emotional.

[idrive1life]

Nevermind. YMMR, FTW then.

[Cdubby]

lol at boourns' signature, thats fucking classic.

[bleep]

I had to go with Sigur Ros. MBV is more mind (and ear) shattering, but I found Untitled 8 to be more emotional.

oh, come on now. don't be a pussy.

[betao]

neck and neck. kinda

[Backwater]

have you been to live MBV garrett?

I'm just going to go out on a limb here and take a guess, no.

[mvanwinkle]

If you were at the berkely show that would be any easy one. The intensity with the rain going as the build up for untitled 8 was going ahhhh i still cant get over it.

[Neutral Milk Hotel]

Nothing beats You Made Me Realise.

[mvanwinkle]

besides untitled 8 of course

[JSam67]

This is a really tough one. But there are a lot of brilliant, emotional songs out there. Granted, Untitled 8 is one of the best, but there are others. What MBV does during the Holocaust is unlike anything I've ever heard, or will likely ever hear again. It left me totally devoid of thought. I liked that.

YMMR

[paulb]

sigur ros.

[Goodtoknow]

Untitled 8.

[Boourns]

Radiohead - House of Cards is the best set closer ever.

[SFChrissy]

If you were at the berkely show that would be any easy one. The intensity with the rain going as the build up for untitled 8 was going ahhhh i still cant get over it.

that's for ephing sure that was one of the most intense show moments iKve been apart of!!! Sasha can vouche for that!!!

[humanoid]

Radiohead - House of Cards is the best set closer ever.

that's the only Radiohead song that I wish I would never hear again

[Boourns]

that's the only Radiohead song that I wish I would never hear again

That, Go to Sleep, and Punchup at a Wedding. But I don't think the last two ever will again.

[JSam67]

Go to Sleep, Boourns? Man, I love that one.