David Gilmour

[moviebruin]

Bank on it. I know im a lurker and be my guest and flame away. But, when monday rolls around and he's a headliner you guys can remember who called it.

[bballarl]

David Gilmour or Roger Waters would be interesting. I would prefer Oasis.

[kreutz2112]

I would be glad if either of them were there.

[TeamCoachellaHellYeah]

hmm.....not really sayin he is confirmed but seems to be sure about it...hmmmm

[bmack86]

I highly doubt it.

[crazzz2007]

YES for Gilmour

[bballarl]

I would only watch Gilmour if he changed the spelling of his last name to Gilmore.

[thelastgreatman]

Heh. This is funny.

[Cdubby]

okay really stupid question, but would he play floyd songs? or does he have a whole other catalog of songs that he would use, and who plays with him?!

just bring Pink Floyd back!

[TeamCoachellaHellYeah]

no he'll be there with the Floyd...

[brando4n82]

okay really stupid question, but would he play floyd songs? or does he have a whole other catalog of songs that he would use, and who plays with him?!

just bring Pink Floyd back!

He came out with a new album in 2006 called "On an Island." It is absolutely Phenomenal. I saw him in 2006 and he played all of On an Island, and a set of Floyd songs including Shine on and Echoes in its entirety. need i really say more than Echoes?

anyhoo. I would LOVE it if i got a second chance to see him, but it seems very doubtful, he hasnt played since about October '06. I think Roger Waters would be more likey, his stage production is great. he put on great shows in 06 and 07 at the Bowl. He almost compares to Gilmour. I hope you are right moviebruin

[brando4n82]

First set: On an Island Full Album


Intermission

Second Set:
Shine On You Crazy Diamond
(Wot's... Uh The Deal)
Wearing The Inside Out
(Fat Old Sun)
Breathe
Time & Breathe reprise
(Dominoes)
(Coming Back To Life)
High Hopes
Echoes

Encores:
Wish You Were Here
Comfortably Numb

[Ritestyl]

Part of me doubts this majorly... would Goldenvoice really bank on everyone knowing who he is and make him a headliner?

[Cdubby]

First set: On an Island Full Album


Intermission

Second Set:
Shine On You Crazy Diamond
(Wot's... Uh The Deal)
Wearing The Inside Out
(Fat Old Sun)
Breathe
Time & Breathe reprise
(Dominoes)
(Coming Back To Life)
High Hopes
Echoes

Encores:
Wish You Were Here
Comfortably Numb

oh thats amazing, i could live with this addition- no problem at all!

[brando4n82]

Part of me doubts this majorly... would Goldenvoice really bank on everyone knowing who he is and make him a headliner?

ya Roger Waters would make a whole lot more sense. But David Gilmour is the better musician soo...

[judila]

light side of the sun...

That's all I'm sayin'...

[Ritestyl]

ya Roger Waters would make a whole lot more sense. But David Gilmour is the better musician soo...

true, but as it has been said many times headliners are about a big draw and selling tickets and to me David Gilmour doesn't fit that mold...

[thelastgreatman]

Waters:

Gilmour:

I'd almost like to make a poll for it but I hate polls so we'll vote here. Which would you rather see at the Polo Fields based on those two clips? Gilmour's solo KILLS it, his voice is a hell of an improvement over the bullshit replacement Waters uses, but Waters has the huge backing band and like the video screen, while Gilmour has more laser work.

[brando4n82]

hence, Waters making more sense. but yes, i agree

[Cdubby]

ya Roger Waters would make a whole lot more sense. But David Gilmour is the better musician soo...

i've always liked gilmour over waters, and i assume the majority of the public does too.

[brando4n82]

ya. Gilmours got the Guitar skillzz AND the Voice. Roger doesnt, his concerts work, because he has prominent female back up singers. Waters has a damn good stand in for Gilmour, but you cant be the real deal. I think we all know who my vote goes to. What do YOU think Randy

[brando4n82]

i've always liked gilmour over waters, and i assume the majority of the public does too.

Unfortunately I believe the majority likes Waters more, but us true fans know the truth

[thelastgreatman]

Waters is the genius behind why they were great. He made their shows legendary. But Gilmour is definitely the performing talent. Honestly? I wish we'd just get Floyd again without Waters and have them put on a show like the Division Bell Tour. That shit slayed all:

[nahuatldream]

I have always admired Waters' writing ability. Some of the stuff on The Wall literally blew me away, it was so crisp and spot on. I have always liked Gilmour's vocals a lot more, however. Couple that with the fact that I saw Waters last year and have never seen Gilmour, I'd vote for Gilmour.

[brando4n82]

oh yeah, and with Gilmour, you get Richard Wright

EDIT: and Dick Parry

[brando4n82]

Waters is the genius behind why they were great. He made their shows legendary. But Gilmour is definitely the performing talent. Honestly? I wish we'd just get Floyd again without Waters and have them put on a show like the Division Bell Tour. That shit slayed all:

fair enough

[Neutral Milk Hotel]

I'm not very familiar with Gilmour's solo stuff, and Gilmour playing Pink Floyd songs has a limited appeal for me, since Roger Waters was such a huge part of the creation of some of their greatest songs. I'm sure the songs sound great from Gilmour but it wouldn't be the same. I would still watch him, though.

[thelastgreatman]

I don't want either one playing though unless they're going to put on a better light spectacle than either of those solo clips. They're fucking Floyd, they should at least have as much cool laser shit as Tool the last leg of their tour.

[luckyface]

I have a better chance of hearing Great Gig in the Sky and Us and Them with Waters, so he gets my vote.

[TeamCoachellaHellYeah]

the more I think about it...the more I'd would rather have a PF show or nothing at all...by that I mean No Gilmour or Waters solos...